Roig Lawyers Partner Tara E. Faenza Secures Second Appellate Victory in High-Profile Miami Land Use Dispute for Iconbrickell Condominium No. Two Association, Inc.
Successful rulings reinforce fundamental due process rights and the importance of community participation in land use decisions.
Roig Lawyers is proud to announce a significant appellate victory secured by Partner Tara E. Faenza in a high-profile land use dispute involving a proposed luxury condominium development in Miami’s Brickell neighborhood in City of Miami v. Iconbrickell Condominium No. Two Association, Inc., et al. Case Number 3D2026-1756. The Miami-Dade Circuit Court, acting in its appellate capacity, and Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal rendered favorable rulings for Icon 2 to reinforce fundamental due process rights of property owners and their ability to participate in decisions that directly affect their communities.
The case arose from a years’-long legal battle involving proposed redevelopment near the historic Brickell First Presbyterian Church (“Church”) by Iconbrickell Condominium No. Two Association, Inc. (“Icon 2”). Development plans by developer 13th Floor Investments called for an 80-story luxury residential tower, called 619 Brickell (Nobu Residences Miami), significantly transforming the surrounding area. To move forward, portions of the Church’s historic designations needed to be removed through proceedings before the City of Miami’s Historic and Environmental Preservation Board (“HEPB”).
Roig Lawyers represented Icon 2, a neighboring homeowners’ association, located approximately 160 feet from the proposed development site. Despite its close proximity and potential exposure to significant impacts from the Nobu project, Icon 2 was denied the opportunity to intervene in proceedings and formally present its concerns and denied standing to appeal before the City Commission.
At the heart of the dispute was a fundamental legal question: Do affected property owners have the right to be heard before government decisions are made that could substantially impact their property and surrounding community?
Under applicable municipal regulations, qualifying neighboring property owners are afforded certain participation rights in land use proceedings. However, Icon 2’s attempts to exercise those rights were denied, prompting legal challenges centered on procedural fairness, standing, and due process.
Led by Faenza, Roig Lawyers developed an appellate strategy grounded in decades of established legal precedent, emphasizing the essential principles of notice, fairness, and the opportunity to be heard. The firm’s arguments demonstrated why these procedural protections must be upheld when government decisions directly affect neighboring property owners.
The litigation presented unique challenges, including opposing arguments from multiple parties, one of which was the City of Miami. The appellate proceedings also required navigating strict briefing limitations and the narrow scope of judicial review.
Following a favorable ruling in the Miami-Dade Circuit Court, in Iconbrickell Condominium No. Two Association, Inc. vs First Presbyterian Church et al. , Case No. 2025-000044-AP-0, the City of Miami filed a Petition for Writ of Certiorari before Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal for second-tier certiorari review. This highly limited form of appellate review focuses on whether procedural due process was afforded and whether the lower court applied the correct law.
Roig Lawyers successfully defended its Icon 2’s favorable ruling, securing another victory before the Third District Court of Appeal. The decision upheld the lower appellate court’s determination that Icon 2 had been improperly denied the opportunity to participate in the HEPB proceedings as an intervenor.
The outcome represents an important affirmation of procedural due process in land use matters, reinforcing that government decision-making must respect the participation rights afforded to qualifying affected property owners.
Beyond the favorable rulings, the case highlights a critical lesson for attorneys, property owners, and organizations navigating complex administrative proceedings: the importance of preserving a clear and comprehensive legal record.
Through careful documentation, strategic legal research, and focused appellate advocacy, Roig Lawyers was able to protect its client’s rights and successfully navigate multiple levels of judicial review.
This victory underscores Roig Lawyers’ commitment to providing strategic, results-driven representation in complex appellate and land use disputes. It also reflects the firm’s ability to address challenging legal issues involving governmental decisions, property rights, and procedural protections.
Congratulations to Partner Tara E. Faenza on this significant appellate victory and her continued dedication to protecting clients’ interests through effective legal advocacy.
To learn more about Roig Lawyers and our appellate and litigation capabilities, visit www.roiglawyers.com.
